The Further Adventures of the Keith Family
Oct. 7th, 2026 09:26 amThe Caine Mutiny has been one of my favourite books since I was a teenager. I don’t know whether it is much read today; a 1951 novel about World War II probably doesn’t seem as relevant now as it did when I was growing up in (what I now recognize as) the post-WWII years. Fans of Hollywood's golden age will remember Humphrey Bogart's iconic performance as the paranoid Captain Queeg in the 1954 movie.

Humphrey Bogart as Captain Queeg
At any rate, The Caine Mutiny occupies an outsize piece of real estate in my brain. It is, among other things, a coming-of-age story about the growth of Willis Seward “Willie” Keith from a spoiled mama’s boy to the captain of the Caine. When not aboard the Caine, a good deal of the story concerns Willie’s romance with May Wynn (née Marie Menotti), a night-club singer from an impoverished Italian immigrant family. At the end of the book, Willie, who had previously broken up with May on the grounds that the class difference between them is unbridgeable, has returned from the war determined to make her his wife. Will he succeed? We’ll never know. Or will we?
Often, when I read a work of fiction, I speculate about what will happen to the characters after the end of the book. (Will Scarlett O’Hara and Rhett Butler get back together? I don’t know and I don’t care, but I’m convinced that Ashley Wilkes will move to England.) I started thinking about whether Willie and May would get married, and ended up imagining a whole future for their family, almost up to the present.
So here it is… the further adventures of the Keith family.
Willie and May get married. Willie, who majored in comparative literature at Princeton (this is canon), is able to live out his dream of becoming a college professor – he belongs to the last generation that will be able to do that. He gets a tenured position at a school in the Midwest; I picture some place like Ames, Iowa. May – or rather, Marie, because she gives up her stage name when she gives up her night-club act – is happy to leave behind the struggle to make a living and become a postwar housewife in a little detached house with a yard. It’s more luxury than she ever imagined she would have. With her beautiful singing voice and her stage experience, she is a great acquisition for the local community theatre.
Marie’s parents sell the fruit store in the Bronx and, with Willie’s help, move to a little house in the same town as Willie and Marie. They spend their later years growing vegetables in their back yard and providing emotional support to their grandchildren. Willie and Marie ask Willie’s mother to move closer to them also, but are relieved when she chooses to stay in New York.
Willie and Marie have two children. Following the Italian custom, they name their son after his paternal grandfather and their daughter after her maternal grandmother. Their son is named Willis Wynn Keith – Willis for his father and grandfather, Wynn for his mother’s stage name – and is called Bill. Their daughter is named Serafina, but is called Sara. Bill is a high achiever – in school, in piano (he inherited the family musical talent), in Boy Scouts – who likes getting recognition for his achievements. Sara struggles in school. She likes hands-on work, such as helping her grandparents in their vegetable garden. Both children feel that their father is disappointed in them.
Bill turns 18 in 1968, just in time for the Vietnam war. By that time Willie is a left-leaning academic who opposes the war. Yet he is proud of his own service in World War II. Bill resents this. Against his parents’ wishes, he joins the Navy. This is not the worst place to be during the Vietnam war, but it is bad enough to leave him confused and traumatized. He flounders for a while after coming home, but eventually establishes a career as a music therapist. He marries a widow whose husband was killed in Vietnam. For whatever reason, Bill and his wife don’t have any children. Her son from her first marriage is Willie and Marie’s only grandchild.
Sara also has her problems as a young adult. She wants to learn a trade, but that is pretty difficult for a woman in the 1970s. She is also a lesbian, a fact that she keeps hidden from her father. Despite his somewhat liberal politics, he has rather archaic ideas about sex and gender (this too is canon). Eventually, with the help of her grandfather, Sara becomes the apprentice of an old Italian cabinetmaker. She lives in Colorado with her partner, and keeps her distance from her parents, though she is close to her brother.
Willie dies in 1979, at age 59, of lung cancer. He always smoked too much (canon). Marie lives long enough to vote for Obama in 2008.
As of 2026, Bill and Sara are both in their 70s, and retired. Sara and her partner are into adventure travel, though they realize that they are getting a little old for that. Bill plays in a band with some other old guys. His stepson lives a conventional life in the suburbs with his wife, a nurse. Their children are young adults. But I won’t follow them into the next generation. Enough is enough.

Humphrey Bogart as Captain Queeg
At any rate, The Caine Mutiny occupies an outsize piece of real estate in my brain. It is, among other things, a coming-of-age story about the growth of Willis Seward “Willie” Keith from a spoiled mama’s boy to the captain of the Caine. When not aboard the Caine, a good deal of the story concerns Willie’s romance with May Wynn (née Marie Menotti), a night-club singer from an impoverished Italian immigrant family. At the end of the book, Willie, who had previously broken up with May on the grounds that the class difference between them is unbridgeable, has returned from the war determined to make her his wife. Will he succeed? We’ll never know. Or will we?
Often, when I read a work of fiction, I speculate about what will happen to the characters after the end of the book. (Will Scarlett O’Hara and Rhett Butler get back together? I don’t know and I don’t care, but I’m convinced that Ashley Wilkes will move to England.) I started thinking about whether Willie and May would get married, and ended up imagining a whole future for their family, almost up to the present.
So here it is… the further adventures of the Keith family.
Willie and May get married. Willie, who majored in comparative literature at Princeton (this is canon), is able to live out his dream of becoming a college professor – he belongs to the last generation that will be able to do that. He gets a tenured position at a school in the Midwest; I picture some place like Ames, Iowa. May – or rather, Marie, because she gives up her stage name when she gives up her night-club act – is happy to leave behind the struggle to make a living and become a postwar housewife in a little detached house with a yard. It’s more luxury than she ever imagined she would have. With her beautiful singing voice and her stage experience, she is a great acquisition for the local community theatre.
Marie’s parents sell the fruit store in the Bronx and, with Willie’s help, move to a little house in the same town as Willie and Marie. They spend their later years growing vegetables in their back yard and providing emotional support to their grandchildren. Willie and Marie ask Willie’s mother to move closer to them also, but are relieved when she chooses to stay in New York.
Willie and Marie have two children. Following the Italian custom, they name their son after his paternal grandfather and their daughter after her maternal grandmother. Their son is named Willis Wynn Keith – Willis for his father and grandfather, Wynn for his mother’s stage name – and is called Bill. Their daughter is named Serafina, but is called Sara. Bill is a high achiever – in school, in piano (he inherited the family musical talent), in Boy Scouts – who likes getting recognition for his achievements. Sara struggles in school. She likes hands-on work, such as helping her grandparents in their vegetable garden. Both children feel that their father is disappointed in them.
Bill turns 18 in 1968, just in time for the Vietnam war. By that time Willie is a left-leaning academic who opposes the war. Yet he is proud of his own service in World War II. Bill resents this. Against his parents’ wishes, he joins the Navy. This is not the worst place to be during the Vietnam war, but it is bad enough to leave him confused and traumatized. He flounders for a while after coming home, but eventually establishes a career as a music therapist. He marries a widow whose husband was killed in Vietnam. For whatever reason, Bill and his wife don’t have any children. Her son from her first marriage is Willie and Marie’s only grandchild.
Sara also has her problems as a young adult. She wants to learn a trade, but that is pretty difficult for a woman in the 1970s. She is also a lesbian, a fact that she keeps hidden from her father. Despite his somewhat liberal politics, he has rather archaic ideas about sex and gender (this too is canon). Eventually, with the help of her grandfather, Sara becomes the apprentice of an old Italian cabinetmaker. She lives in Colorado with her partner, and keeps her distance from her parents, though she is close to her brother.
Willie dies in 1979, at age 59, of lung cancer. He always smoked too much (canon). Marie lives long enough to vote for Obama in 2008.
As of 2026, Bill and Sara are both in their 70s, and retired. Sara and her partner are into adventure travel, though they realize that they are getting a little old for that. Bill plays in a band with some other old guys. His stepson lives a conventional life in the suburbs with his wife, a nurse. Their children are young adults. But I won’t follow them into the next generation. Enough is enough.


































